A small New Hampshire coffee producer that operates out of a barn has prevailed in a trademark infringement case brought by Starbucks over a blend called "Charbucks."
Charbucks, introduced in 1997, is Black Bear's darkest roast coffee. The appeals court noted that "one of the reasons Black Bear used the term 'Charbucks' was the public perception that Starbucks roasted its beans unusually darkly." But it agreed with the district court in finding minimal similarity and weak evidence of actual association between the brands."Their sales haven't been hurt," Clark said, noting that Black Bear's haven't changed much over the years. "Their growth hasn't been hurt."Seattle-based Starbucks respects but disagrees with the court's decision, company spokesman Zack Hutson said."We only filed the suit after a prolonged but unsuccessful attempt to enlist Black Bear's cooperation and to resolve this matter without litigation," Hutson said Monday.Starbucks is a responsible trademark owner and was asking only for an injunction against the use of "Charbucks," he said. The case did not involve monetary damages.Starbucks can ask for a rare hearing before the full appeals court. They also can appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. Hutson didn't indicate whether Starbucks would proceed with further appeals.
"We Don't Have 5 Years": Celebrated American General Sounds Alarm On War
"Certainty Is A Problem": Nikhil Kamath On Marriage, Children And Future
The Mystery Of A Bare Nail In Ashwini Vaishnaw's Office
Paris Setback, Asian Games Glory: Lovlina Borgohain's New Perspective
"There Will Be Issues Between Big Countries": S Jaishankar On India-China
Neha Goyal Makes Stunning Asian Games Gold Revelation At NDTV World Summit 2026
RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra Drops Big Hint On Tata Sons Listing Row At NDTV World Summit
Big NDTV Summit Impact: RBI Governor's Tata Sons Listing Remark Makes Top Newspaper Headlines
"High Inflation Is Like Tax On Everyone": RBI Governor At NDTV World Summit
AI Assistants Are Both Frightening And Empowering, Says Mike Walsh
Charbucks, introduced in 1997, is Black Bear's darkest roast coffee. The appeals court noted that "one of the reasons Black Bear used the term 'Charbucks' was the public perception that Starbucks roasted its beans unusually darkly." But it agreed with the district court in finding minimal similarity and weak evidence of actual association between the brands."Their sales haven't been hurt," Clark said, noting that Black Bear's haven't changed much over the years. "Their growth hasn't been hurt."Seattle-based Starbucks respects but disagrees with the court's decision, company spokesman Zack Hutson said."We only filed the suit after a prolonged but unsuccessful attempt to enlist Black Bear's cooperation and to resolve this matter without litigation," Hutson said Monday.Starbucks is a responsible trademark owner and was asking only for an injunction against the use of "Charbucks," he said. The case did not involve monetary damages.Starbucks can ask for a rare hearing before the full appeals court. They also can appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court. Hutson didn't indicate whether Starbucks would proceed with further appeals.