Over the past weekend, I participated in a couple of conferences where the clinical community discussed new trends in diet and nutrition and their scientific authenticity. We all agree that diets need to be personalised, with scientific evidence as a guideline. However, beyond a certain point, we're unable to predict how a particular nutrient may affect an individual. From here, our conversation veered towards nutrigenetics, a discipline that explores how individual genetic differences affect dietary needs. The DNA diet, as it's commonly referred to, aims for a personalised approach to nutrition based on one's genetic makeup. Many companies have emerged with this approach, promising to enhance health outcomes by aligning diet with DNA. While still an evolving science, a growing body of research supports the integration of genetic data into nutritional planning.
Also Read: Are You Obese? Your Child Could Inherit Obesity and Be At Health Risk
What Exactly Is DNA Diet?
A DNA diet involves tailoring nutritional recommendations to an individual's genetic profile. Specific genes can influence how a person metabolises nutrients, responds to different types of diets, or is predisposed to conditions like obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease. By identifying genetic variants, healthcare providers can design more effective dietary interventions.
Some key genes studied in the context of nutrigenetics include:
- FTO (Fat Mass and Obesity-Associated Gene): Variants are associated with increased appetite and obesity risk and may benefit from higher protein intake to manage weight.
- MTHFR (Methylenetetrahydrofolate Reductase): Involved in folate metabolism.
- CYP1A2: Regulates caffeine metabolism, and certain genotypes may increase the risk of hypertension and myocardial infarction when consuming high caffeine.
- LCT (Lactase): Determines lactose tolerance.
- APOE: Influences lipid metabolism and cardiovascular risk.
DNA diet tailors nutrition requirements as per an individual's genetic profile.
Clinical Evidence and Benefits Of DNA Diet:
The effectiveness of this approach is rapidly expanding. A randomised trial by Arkadianos et al. (2007) demonstrated that individuals following a genetically tailored diet lost more weight and maintained the loss more effectively than those on a standard diet. Another systematic review by Celis-Morales et al. (2015) in Advances in Nutrition found that DNA-informed dietary advice led to improved eating habits and motivation compared to general guidelines. Then, in 2014, Nielsen and El-Sohemy reported in PLoS One that personalised nutrition advice based on DNA testing was better received and more likely to be followed than generic dietary advice.
Also Read: Study Suggests Genetic Mutation May Help Control Sugar Cravings
Challenges Of Following DNA Diet
Despite promising results, several challenges persist:
- Genetic influences on diet are complex and often involve multiple genes with small effect sizes.
- Environmental and lifestyle factors can modulate genetic expression (epigenetics).
- Ethical considerations exist around data privacy and direct-to-consumer testing.
- The clinical utility of many genetic variants is still being validated in large, diverse populations.
So, while the DNA diet represents a frontier in personalised medicine, offering a tailored approach to nutrition that considers the individual's genetic blueprint, the verdict is still out there. While more robust, long-term studies are needed to fully validate its effectiveness, current research supports its potential to improve health outcomes. For best results, DNA-based diets should be integrated into a comprehensive healthcare plan guided by qualified professionals.
About Rupali DattaRupali Datta is a Clinical Nutritionist and has worked in leading corporate hospitals. She has created and lead teams of professionals to deliver clinical solutions for patients across all medical specialties including critical care. She is a member of the Indian Dietetic Association and Indian Association of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition.